Knights News Challenge Winners

Can I enter in more than one category?

Yes, if you have more than one proposal. But you may not submit the same proposal in multiple categories.

You
may even enter as an individual in one category and as part of a
nonprofit or company in another category, providing that the proposals
are different.

Can I enter both the Young Creators Award and the Knight News Challenge?

The Young Creators Award is one of the three
categories in the Knight News Challenge (the others are 'general' and
'commercial').  If you enter the Young Creators Award, you may not also
submit the same idea in another category.  (You may, however, submit a
different idea in any of the categories.)

Will you really fund a for-profit company?

Yes, if the company is uniquely positioned to test or develop a new technique or technology and is willing to share the results of that test with everyone. We see the challenge as a kind of flexible research and development fund, open to anyone.

How many awards will you give in each category?

Anywhere from zero to a large number.

It depends on the number of quality proposals we get.

Do I hold the intellectual property rights for my idea?

Yes. The applicant holds the intellectual property rights, subject to
Knight Foundation’s requirement that the intellectual property be
shared with the world. By entering the contest you agree to share those
rights with the world in line with open-source, open-standard
philosophy. If you enter your idea as an “open” idea, others can
comment on it. They are freely giving you their wisdom, and by doing
that, they are agreeing to let you incorporate their ideas into your
project. If you win, however, under the open-source rules you’ll have
to share your software code and other know-how with everyone.

What if I submit an “open’’ entry and someone “steals” my idea?

That could happen. It’s the trade-off of that
category. You can seek the wisdom of the crowd and use it to improve
your entry. It would be possible for someone to read your idea and
submit a similar one in the open or closed category. If someone
submitted a similar proposal to yours and did so in the closed
category, you probably never would know that your idea had been copied.
Submitting in the closed category would avoid this situation but would
prevent you from getting ideas from others that might improve your
application. During Knight Foundation’s process of reviewing
applications, we might be able to identify ideas that appear to be
copies and to decline applications that appear to be copies but we
cannot promise to do that. 

Entering
“openly” means you are either confident enough in your own abilities
and track record that you’ll be chosen to do the work even if others
have similar ideas, or that you don’t really care who does the work as
long as it gets done. If someone copies your idea and then submits a
“closed” application, you might not ever know that happened. The only
way to avoid that situation is to submit your entry as a closed entry.

Can
I claim a piece of someone else’s prize if I give them the idea (in the
open entry) that propels their project into a winning category?
[top]

Only
if you are a co-applicant. Otherwise, if you comment on an entry you
are doing so freely and voluntarily with the knowledge that you are not
creating any ownership rights for yourself.  It is theoretically
possible for a technology expert with a good entry to meet up through
the comment process with a community expert and want to invite them to
join in as a partner in a revised entry. But that’s up to the original
applicant.

What if I’m a minor and I win, and my parents are divorced or I have another legal guardian? Can I decide which of my guardians receives the award money?

No. Knight Foundation will select an intermediary who is not a family member to manage the money for you.

What if my project is a total failure?

f you are awarded a grant, Knight Foundation will work with you to help
you succeed. We will bring our resources and experience to your aid,
where feasible. Nonetheless, sometimes ideas still don’t work out. If
that happens, the important thing is to learn from the experience.
That’s why we call these projects “community news experiments”.
Experiments fail all the time, but at least if you are rigorously
honest, you learn what didn’t work.

Are winnings taxable?

Because individual situations vary, you need to consult a professional tax adviser with this question.

You said you don’t want to pay money for people to blog, so why are there “blogger winners”? How are they different?

We don’t have a problem with blogs. But paying someone to blog about
the local school board is not a digital innovation. A person can do
that right now, without this contest. The blogs we support are for the
purpose of publicly developing new ideas of how to create community
news experiments using digital innovation. We also ask all winners to
blog about their projects, as part of their obligation to share their
knowledge.

If two people enter as a team, who gets the money?

The award money would be distributed to both of them. Each person would
have equal claim on the money unless they agree between themselves, and
tell us clearly, that they wish a different distribution because of
different contributions to the application.

I heard that employees of former Knight-Ridder newspapers are not eligible to enter.

We face IRS restrictions in giving to the Miami Herald, the Akron Beacon Journal and the Detroit Free Press because these former Knight-Ridder newspapers once gave contributions to the foundation. But employees of those papers may still apply for individual news challenge awards. There are, however, exceptions, including officers or directors of those newspapers or their parent companies. The best way to find out whether or not you are eligible is to apply. When employees apply, they must apply as individuals, and not propose to use any company resources, time or intellectual property rights.

Have a question we didn't answer?

Paul Johnson

[]
photo_amy_gahran.jpg

The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments.
2008 Knight News Challenge Update

The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.

Project Summary
Goals

$109,009

to Test 1

Awarded to Paul [MIT Media Lab/Comparative Media Studies]
The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments. 2008 Knight News Challenge Update The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.
photo_amy_gahran.jpg

Samsung Samsung

[]
photo_lisa_williams.jpg

The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments.
2008 Knight News Challenge Update

The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.

Project Summary
Goals

$123,000

to Test 2

Awarded to Samsung Samsung []
The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments. 2008 Knight News Challenge Update The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.
photo_lisa_williams.jpg
test test test tset

Sasoon season

[]
photo_jay_rosen.jpg

The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments.
2008 Knight News Challenge Update

The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.

Project Summary The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments. 2008 Knight News Challenge Update The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.
Goals

$1,234,000

to Test 3

Awarded to Sasoon season []
The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments. 2008 Knight News Challenge Update The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.
photo_jay_rosen.jpg
this that this

Jonathan Black

[]
photo_nora_paul.jpg

The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments.
2008 Knight News Challenge Update

The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.

Project Summary The Knight News Challenge is a contest awarding as much as $5 million a year for innovative ideas using digital experiments to transform community news. Last year’s winners included a diverse collection of 33 individuals, private and public entities, ranging from MIT to MTV. Knight Foundation plans to invest at least $25 million over five years in the search for bold community news experiments. 2008 Knight News Challenge Update The decision-making process has concluded. Seventeen projects have been chosen. The 2008 winners will be announced at the Editor & Publisher Interactive Media Conference in Las Vegas on May 14, 2008.
Goals